While many fans once dreamed of Tony DiNozzo and Ziva David reuniting on NCIS, a surprising wave of backlash has emerged after rumors of their return gained traction. Longtime viewers are voicing concerns that bringing the beloved pair back could overshadow the current cast and disrupt the show’s new direction. Some feel the emotional weight of their past stories has already been beautifully closed—and reopening that chapter could feel forced.

One major concern is how their return might impact character development. With new leads like Alden Parker and Jessica Knight finally settling in, fans worry that shifting focus back to Tony and Ziva could undo the balance NCIS has worked hard to build in recent seasons. “Let the new team breathe,” one viewer wrote. “We said goodbye to Tony and Ziva years ago. It was painful, but it mattered.”

Others point out that the characters’ arcs were already given fitting, emotional conclusions—Ziva’s survival and reunion with Tony and their daughter felt like the perfect ending. Reviving their storyline could, some argue, cheapen the impact of their departures and feel more like fan service than strong storytelling.

Still, not everyone agrees. A large part of the fandom remains hopeful for at least a guest appearance or closure scene. But as of now, it’s clear that while some miss Tony and Ziva deeply, others believe the show must continue moving forward without looking back.